Menu & Specials
Tonight's Drink Special
Drink
Captains & Imports
$3
Daily drink special · 8 PM – 12 AM
Gourmet Burgers
9 dishesComes with a side: Crispy fries · Sweet fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet fries, steak fries or soup.

Andy Burger
Bacon, mushrooms & american cheese. Skip the mushrooms for a classic BLT Burger.

Western Burger
Bacon, bbq sauce & cheddar cheese.

Deli Burger
Topped with ham, genoa salami, pepperoni & provolone cheese.

Italian Burger
Topped with banana peppers, provolone & Italian seasoning.

Breakfast Burger
Topped with a fried egg, bacon & American cheese.

Pub Burger
Grilled in Gold bbq sauce then topped off with bacon, breaded onions and pepper jack cheese.

Traditional Burger
Not just the old standard burger. Here at Andy's we use the finest ground beef available. Half-pound cooked just the way you like. Plain or with american cheese.
Mexi Burger
Diced tomatoes, black olives, banana peppers and Andy's special chipotle sauce topped off with cheddar cheese.
Cheesy Deluxe
Swiss, american, pepper jack & provolone.
Melts
5 dishesComes with a side: Crispy fries · Sweet fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet fries, steak fries or soup.

Tuna Melt
White albacore tuna, melted american cheese with tomato.

Ham & Swiss Melt
Shaved ham piled high & smothered in swiss. Served with tomato.

Club Melt
Ham, turkey, tomato, swiss & American cheese.

The Sicilian Melt
Ham, salami, pepperoni topped with banana peppers and provolone.
Turkey & Swiss Melt
Shaved turkey piled high & smothered in swiss. Served with tomato.
Sandwiches
11 dishesComes with a side: Crispy fries · Sweet fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet fries, steak fries or soup.

Turkey Sandwich
Turkey piled high with lettuce & tomato. Served on sourdough bread.

Grilled Cheese
VegetarianAmerican, swiss, provolone & pepper jack. These four cheeses topped with tomato make for a great vegetarian alternative. Served on sourdough bread.

BLT
An American classic. Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Served on sourdough bread.

Italian Chicken Fillet
Grilled with the finest Italian seasonings topped off with provolone cheese & banana peppers. Served on a kaiser roll.

Fish Sandwich
Catch of the day served with tartar sauce. Served on a kaiser roll.

Ham & Swiss on Pretzel Roll
Served with lettuce & tomato on the side.

Turkey & Swiss on Pretzel Roll
Served with lettuce & tomato on the side.
Club Sandwich
Ham, turkey, swiss, american, lettuce, tomato & mayo. Served on sourdough bread.
Chicken Fillet
Boneless white breast with bacon, mushrooms & swiss. Served on a kaiser roll.
BBQ Chicken Fillet
Grilled with bacon, bbq sauce & topped with cheddar. Served on a kaiser roll.
Italian Sausage
Topped with grilled onions, peppers & provolone cheese. Served on a kaiser roll.
Dinners
5 dishes
Low Carb Combo
Our famous gourmet burger topped with american cheese & bacon coupled alongside a delicious chicken fillet topped with bacon & swiss served on a bed of lettuce.

Sirloin Strip
Seasoned with Andy's special steak seasoning, this 8 ounce strip is sure to please the steak lover.

Surf & Turf
Can't decide whether to go land or sea? Our 8 ounce sirloin coupled alongside 6 ounces of delicious breaded shrimp. Guaranteed to satisfy both of your cravings.
Catch of the Day
Prepared with a flaky beer battered coating.
Shrimp Dinner
12 ounces of 31/35 count breaded shrimp served with cocktail sauce.
Wraps
8 dishesComes with a side: Crispy fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet potato fries or chili.

Chicken Caesar Wrap
Your classic chicken caesar rolled up in a fresh tortilla wrap.

TCB Wrap
Turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo.

Ham & Swiss Wrap
Served with lettuce, tomato and mayo.

Philly Steak Wrap
Thin cut sirloin smothered in onions, peppers & provolone.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Breaded chicken breast, bacon, lettuce, cheddar cheese dressed with ranch.
Italian Deli Wrap
Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion & Italian dressing.
Crunchy Chicken Chipotle Wrap
Breaded chicken breast, lettuce, cheddar cheese dressed with chipotle sauce.
Turkey & Swiss Wrap
Served with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Salads
7 dishes
Rainbow Pasta Salad
Rainbow rotini, tomatoes, olives, ham, pepperoni, salami, swiss, provolone & hot peppers with Andy's own dressing.

Charbroiled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken over lettuce with onions, black olives, tomatoes and a sprinkling of grated parmesan.

Steak Salad
Thin cut sirloin steak topped with black olives, onions, tomato & shredded mozzarella.

Antipasto Salad
Ham, salami, pepperoni, swiss & provolone cheese. Topped with hot banana peppers and a sprinkling of grated parmesan.
Chicken Rotini Salad
Grilled chicken served over our rainbow rotini.
Chef Salad
Andy's superb creation with ham, turkey, bacon, swiss & american cheeses. Topped with tomatoes and black olives and a sprinkling of grated parmesan.
Crispy Chicken Salad
Breaded white breast served over lettuce with tomatoes, olives, topped with cheddar cheese.
Wings
1 dishAppetizers
14 dishes
Zucchini
Battered and deep fried. Large basket.

Hot Pretzel
Served with a tangy mustard sauce.

Chicken Breast Tenders
Lightly breaded chicken tenders. Add fries for $3.00.

Pizza Logs
5 pizza logs served with marinara sauce.

Cheese Sticks
5 deep fried breaded mozzarella sticks.

Pickles & Poppers
Batter-dipped and deep fried golden.

Crispy Fries
Andy's special seasoned crispy fries. Large basket. Add chili & cheese for $2 extra.

Steak Fries
Steak fries. Large basket. Add chili & cheese for $2 extra.

Sweet Fries
Sweet potato fries. Large basket. Add chili & cheese for $2 extra.

Toasted Ravioli (T-Ravs)
10 breaded & seasoned deep fried ravioli served with marinara.

Jalapeño Poppers
Wisconsin cheddar cheese and diced jalapeño peppers surrounded with an exquisite potato breading.

Mixed Basket
Deep fried zucchini, chicken tender, cheese sticks, onion rings, pickle chips and seasoned crispy fries. We may have to substitute items based on availability.

Breaded Fantail Shrimp
Six ounces butterflied shrimp served with cocktail sauce.

Onion Rings
Batter-dipped and deep fried golden. Large basket.
Year Round Soups
2 dishesSides
4 dishesPizza
16 dishesSM $13.99 · MD $17.99 · LG $19.99
Specialty Pizzas
The Works
The ultimate loaded pizza with all the toppings.
The Meats
Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, beef, bacon & Canadian bacon.
Garden Fresh
Fresh vegetables on a bed of cheese.
Spicy Italian
Italian sausage, salami & banana peppers with a kick.
BBQ Chicken & Bacon
Grilled chicken, bacon & onions with BBQ sauce.
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken
Grilled chicken, pineapple & bacon with BBQ sauce.
Tuscan 6 Cheese
A rich blend of six Italian cheeses.
Spinach Alfredo
Creamy alfredo sauce with fresh spinach.
Buffalo Chicken
Spicy buffalo chicken with ranch drizzle.
Pizza
Cheese Pizza (Small)
Build your own with extra toppings ($1.50 each).
Cheese Pizza (Medium)
Build your own with extra toppings ($2.00 each).
Cheese Pizza (Large)
Build your own with extra toppings ($2.50 each). Choose Original or Thin crust.
Cheese Sticks
Papa John's cheese sticks.
Bread Sticks
Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks
Dipping Sauces
Cheese, garlic or pizza sauce.
Desserts
1 dishDessert
We serve Papa John's dessert menu. Ask server for available desserts.
Common questions
We're at 3864 Peach Street in Erie, PA — upstairs at Andy's, near the Millcreek Mall, about four miles north of I-90 (Exit 24) and a five-minute drive south of downtown Erie.





