Skip to content

Menu & Specials

Tonight's Drink Special

Drink

Captains & Imports

$3

Daily drink special · 8 PM – 12 AM

Gourmet Burgers

9 dishes

Comes with a side: Crispy fries · Sweet fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet fries, steak fries or soup.

Melts

5 dishes

Comes with a side: Crispy fries · Sweet fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet fries, steak fries or soup.

Sandwiches

11 dishes

Comes with a side: Crispy fries · Sweet fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet fries, steak fries or soup.

Dinners

5 dishes

Wraps

8 dishes

Comes with a side: Crispy fries · Steak fries · Soup (Chicken Tortilla or Soup of the Day) · Onion rings · Tossed salad · Potato salad · Rotini salad. Add $1 for sweet potato fries or chili.

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Your classic chicken caesar rolled up in a fresh tortilla wrap.

$9.95
TCB Wrap

TCB Wrap

Turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo.

$9.95
Ham & Swiss Wrap

Ham & Swiss Wrap

Served with lettuce, tomato and mayo.

$9.95
Philly Steak Wrap

Philly Steak Wrap

Thin cut sirloin smothered in onions, peppers & provolone.

$9.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

Breaded chicken breast, bacon, lettuce, cheddar cheese dressed with ranch.

$9.95

Italian Deli Wrap

Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion & Italian dressing.

$9.95

Crunchy Chicken Chipotle Wrap

Breaded chicken breast, lettuce, cheddar cheese dressed with chipotle sauce.

$9.95

Turkey & Swiss Wrap

Served with lettuce, tomato and mayo.

$9.95

Salads

7 dishes
Rainbow Pasta Salad

Rainbow Pasta Salad

Rainbow rotini, tomatoes, olives, ham, pepperoni, salami, swiss, provolone & hot peppers with Andy's own dressing.

$9.95
Charbroiled Chicken Salad

Charbroiled Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken over lettuce with onions, black olives, tomatoes and a sprinkling of grated parmesan.

$9.95
Steak Salad

Steak Salad

Thin cut sirloin steak topped with black olives, onions, tomato & shredded mozzarella.

$9.95
Antipasto Salad

Antipasto Salad

Ham, salami, pepperoni, swiss & provolone cheese. Topped with hot banana peppers and a sprinkling of grated parmesan.

$9.95

Chicken Rotini Salad

Grilled chicken served over our rainbow rotini.

$9.95

Chef Salad

Andy's superb creation with ham, turkey, bacon, swiss & american cheeses. Topped with tomatoes and black olives and a sprinkling of grated parmesan.

$9.95

Crispy Chicken Salad

Breaded white breast served over lettuce with tomatoes, olives, topped with cheddar cheese.

$9.95

Wings

1 dish

Appetizers

14 dishes

Year Round Soups

2 dishes

Sides

4 dishes

Pizza

16 dishes

SM $13.99 · MD $17.99 · LG $19.99

Specialty Pizzas

The Works

The ultimate loaded pizza with all the toppings.

$13.99 – $19.99

The Meats

Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, beef, bacon & Canadian bacon.

$13.99 – $19.99

Garden Fresh

Fresh vegetables on a bed of cheese.

$13.99 – $19.99

Spicy Italian

Italian sausage, salami & banana peppers with a kick.

$13.99 – $19.99

BBQ Chicken & Bacon

Grilled chicken, bacon & onions with BBQ sauce.

$13.99 – $19.99

Hawaiian BBQ Chicken

Grilled chicken, pineapple & bacon with BBQ sauce.

$13.99 – $19.99

Tuscan 6 Cheese

A rich blend of six Italian cheeses.

$13.99 – $19.99

Spinach Alfredo

Creamy alfredo sauce with fresh spinach.

$13.99 – $19.99

Buffalo Chicken

Spicy buffalo chicken with ranch drizzle.

$13.99 – $19.99

Pizza

Cheese Pizza (Small)

Build your own with extra toppings ($1.50 each).

$11.99

Cheese Pizza (Medium)

Build your own with extra toppings ($2.00 each).

$13.99

Cheese Pizza (Large)

Build your own with extra toppings ($2.50 each). Choose Original or Thin crust.

$15.99

Cheese Sticks

Papa John's cheese sticks.

$8.99

Bread Sticks

$6.99

Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks

$7.99

Dipping Sauces

Cheese, garlic or pizza sauce.

$0.99

Desserts

1 dish

Dessert

We serve Papa John's dessert menu. Ask server for available desserts.

$7.95

Common questions

We're at 3864 Peach Street in Erie, PA — upstairs at Andy's, near the Millcreek Mall, about four miles north of I-90 (Exit 24) and a five-minute drive south of downtown Erie.